I love The Decemberists. So much. It’s been four years since their last studio album and I could not be more excited for the new album to release on Tuesday. As such, I re-listened to all of their studio releases to reacquaint myself with the albums and develop my ranking of least to most favorite. There are definitely worse things I could do to my ears 🙂
6. Castaways and Cutouts
The Decemberists’ first studio album, it’s not as strong as their other releases. There are a few standout tracks – A Cautionary Song is a three-minute long “yo mama” joke that I enjoy very, very much – but the rest aren’t anything to brag about. Granted, the “worst” Decemberists album is still far above a lot of other musical choices.
5. Her Majesty the Decemberists
I promise my rankings aren’t just the order of the discography. One of my favorite Decemberists songs ever – Red Right Ankle – is featured on the album. The songs are a little catchier and the album flows better, not dragging as much as the previous one. On Her Majesty the Decemberists, the band really develops and establishes the sound that flows through the next three releases.
4. The King is Dead
A lot of people have gripes with this album. It’s not my favorite album by the band but it’s definitely not my least favorite. It has a different sound than the others as it ventures into a more folk country vibe. It was a new experiment for the band but I think it works. And I have a lot of respect for a band that takes risks with their sound.
3. The Crane Wife
Admittedly, these last three albums were very difficult to rank. I tried listening to the attached EPs/bonus tracks to help decide and it still didn’t work. But this is what I landed on.
The Crane Wife is beautiful and its out-of-order story tracks make this a dedicated listening experience. This one tends to be a favorite of die-hard Decemberists fans and it is certainly a favorite of mine, but it’s just not quite there for me. It doesn’t hold my attention quite as deeply as the next two. Also, I included any bonus tracks in my judgment of these albums, and while After the Bombs and Culling of the Fold are so good they deserve to be on the album proper, The Perfect Crime #1 is a boring 15 minutes compared to the rest of the tracks.
2. The Hazards of Love
This was my first introduction to the band (I know, I’m late to the game) and it remains a favorite. It’s a concept album and an excellent one at that. I get lost in its story every time I listen to it. Colin Meloy took the concept of his interweaving stories from The Crane Wife and made an album-long rock opera.
There aren’t a lot of “singles” as a result but an album is ultimately an experience. The Hazards of Love provides an excellent experience.
1. Picaresque
In 2009, I bought pizza for a small party at a friend’s house. One of my friends didn’t have cash on hand to pay me back but promised he would shortly. The next time I saw him, he handed me a used CD copy of this album as payment. I think I owe him change.
Picaresque is packed with amazing stand alone tracks that flow well together into one cohesive album. It doesn’t take as much dedication as other Decemberists albums but still contains the unique sound the band is so well-known for. And is there anything better than The Mariner’s Revenge Song?
I am eager to see what What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World has to offer to the band’s discography. Based on their existing repertoire, I have high expectations.